Personal Finance

Don't Panic: Corrections are Normal


Fear knocked on the door. Faith answered. No one was there. 
-English proverb 

Imagine you bought a stock back in 2009 at $7 a share. It had dropped from a high of $15 in 2007. But, the 22 cent dividend gave you a 3.1% yield and the prospects of the price staying so low for long were historically improbable.

The trade worked well. By 2011 your $7 stock had recovered to $12 and the dividend had increased by 18% to just over 26 cents per share. In 2013 it was at $17 surpassing the previous $15 high. By 2015 it was trading between $19 and $21, with a dividend of over 43 cents a share, almost double the amount from where you bought in back in 2009. And, earlier this year it ran to a high of $29 ½. Recently it has backed off to $26 ½. Would you consider it time to sell?

Consider the following: from a valuation standpoint, it sells at 15x next year’s earnings – not that expensive in a 3%, 10-year Treasury world. The cash on cash dividend off your original $7 purchase point is now 7.5%. That would be lost if you sold. Granted, the yield at the current $26 ½ price is just 2%, but your dividend has been compounding at about 9% per annum for the past 10 years. The dividend is expected to continue to grow. And, if you sell now, the after tax proceeds to reinvest would only be about $21 per share* if you sold it in a taxable account.

Of course with the market shaky at the moment, and possibly going lower, you’ll be able to buy your gem of a stock back below $21, right, even though that’s 20% below where it trades at the moment? You’ve always been a great market timer, right? On the other hand, and thinking long-term, over the next year or so there may be a time to add to this great investment at slightly lower prices than $26 1/2.

This anecdote describes the movement of the S&P 500 over the last decade if it were a stock. Serious, long-term investors would no sooner sell this kind of investment—one that has tripled in price—because of a 10% correction, than they would decide to trade bitcoin or dabble in penny stocks.

The message of this story: don’t panic and cave on this market. Corrections are normal. What’s not been normal over the last 10 years is how few corrections of 10% or better we’ve had.

In all likelihood your $26 ½ stock will not triple again in the next ten years. But, the dividends will continue to grow and the appreciation potential will almost certainly beat the 3%, before taxes and inflation, that you can earn on so called “safe” money.

*Assumes a 30% combined top marginal capital gain inclusive of federal capital gains tax, net investment income tax and state capital gain tax.

This note by the President of Janney’s Private Client Group was published on November 21st, 2018.

Janney Montgomery Scott LLC Financial Advisors are available to discuss the suitability and risks involved with various products and strategies presented. We will be happy to provide a prospectus, when available, and other information upon request. Please note that the information provided includes reference to concepts that have legal, accounting, and tax implications. It is not to be construed as legal, accounting, or tax advice and is provided as general information to you to assist in understanding the issues discussed. Neither Janney Montgomery Scott LLC nor its Financial Advisors (in their capacity as Financial Advisors) give tax, legal, or accounting advice. We would urge you to consult with your own attorney and/or accountant regarding the application of the information contained in this letter to the facts and circumstances of your particular situation. Janney Montgomery Scott LLC is a full-service investment firm that is a member of the NYSE, FINRA, and SIPC.

Share this article

Three Questions You Should Ask Your Tax Preparer This Year

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) was signed into law on December 22, 2017, introducing fundamental changes to the Federal tax landscape for both individuals and businesses.



Share this article

Could You Live on $16,848 a Year?

Your Social Security benefit may not be enough for you to live on in retirement.



Share this article

Tips on How Women Can Overcome Investing Challenges

Welcome to Janney's newest podcast, Personal Finance and Investing, a podcast series addressing common financial questions related to a variety of personal life events and financial planning topics. In episode one of this podcast, we explore the unique financial challenges facing women investors.

Please listen and subscribe to Janney Personal Finance and Investing on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play or wherever you stream podcasts.

Share this article